Requiring Public School Uniforms May Infringe on Students' First Amendment Rights

Publication

Requiring Public School Uniforms May Infringe on Students’ First Amendment Rights

Mar 06, 2014

Burke Education Law Alert

On February 14, 2014, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a public school’s policy mandating uniforms, which displayed a logo and written motto, was subject to strict scrutiny because it compelled speech, thus infringing on the students’ First Amendment rights.

In Frudden v. Pilling, the public school instituted a mandatory uniform policy which required students to wear a red or navy polo-style shirt depicting a gopher next to the school name and the motto “Tomorrow’s Leaders.”

Download